Summum Bonem
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

Anarchy, bones, and dystopia

1/25/2018

0 Comments

 

There’s no such thing as an individual, just a pack member and her bones. So claimed a famous dog in the recent past.

Both my house and my workplace have four storeys. I think this is rather a lot – in particular, it means that in my house there’s two empty storeys between where the humans sleep and where I do. I much prefer it when we all bundle onto a sofa together. And I think they do too, even if they do claim they get trampled on from time to time.

Unlike dogs, humans often have a curious habit of seeing being separate and self-reliant as a really good thing, even when it’s not even necessary. It’s seen as a sign of strength to be self-sufficient and independent, and competitiveness is seen as a character strength. On the other hand, being reliant on others is sometimes seen as a sign of weakness – often something to be tolerated in others but not really allowed in oneself. Calling someone 'needy' is an insult, and one that is usually applied to females, who get the worst of these kinds of things. Humans often also construe people in a way that assumes this separateness is how people are – so for example they will speak of humans as ‘individuals’ – so that people aspire to self-sufficiency, without even thinking about it.

Actually, not all humans think separateness is a good thing, and the idea hasn't even always been popular. The word ‘idiot’ comes from the Greek word ‘idios’ which means ‘self’ or ‘belonging to the private world’. So somewhere along the line some people must have recognised that being a self-sufficient individual, or trying to be, is not really that a great a virtue.

One of the areas of philosophy that interests me is philosophy of emotion. Because humans tend to be individualistic, human philosophers often look at an individual's’ emotions – what it’s like for one person to be in love, or feel angry, or be jealous. But some philosophy also looks at collective emotion. What’s the difference between an emotion when it’s felt by several people, rather than merely one person? And mightn’t this actually happen rather a lot? Perhaps the emotion feels different if it’s shared – for example, the feeling of grief may be different if it’s not just felt by one person, but shared by a couple, or close family members, or a close-knit community of friends. And that different feeling wouldn’t be just an ‘add-on’ to individual feelings of grief: it would make the grief totally different in the way it feels, through and through. This might be a kind of ‘off-loading’: in the context of grief, the mourners might share the work of grieving with trusted others.

I’ve been very influenced by the work of Joel Krueger on collective emotion (being a human, I’m not sure whether he shares my dislike of individualism). You can find out more about Joel’s philosophy here.
​
I’m a fan of collective emotion, and also of critiquing individualism (see my earlier post on the human Marx), at certain times - like when it comes to piling on to a sofa with lots of people to watch an emotional film together. All of that said, I’m quite an individualist when it comes to bones.
Picture
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Mental walkies with Lola,
    Professor of Dogic and Dogmatics at the University of Leads.

    Archives

    May 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017

    Categories

    All
    Biscuits
    Bones
    Book Reviews
    CATS
    Delicious Tempting Cheese
    Dogic
    Downward Dog
    Ducks
    Epistemology
    Marx
    Meta-ethics
    Metaphysics
    Muddy Human Challenge
    My Christmas Ambles
    My Favourite Ball
    My Feeding Bowl
    My Humans
    My Leg Ritual
    Other Dogs
    Pets As Therapy
    Philosophy Of Emotion
    Philosophy Of Gender
    Philosophy Of Language
    Philosophy Of Mathematics
    Philosophy Of Mind
    Philosophy Of Psychiatry
    Philosophy Of Religion
    Physics
    Puppies
    Slippers
    Squirrels
    Sticks
    Theology
    UCU Strike
    Wittgenstein

    RSS Feed

    FACEBOOK
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact